Skip to content
The Mental Bloom

How to measure business success when you are the business

Overhead view of a notebook page divided into four blank boxes, with a pencil and a mug

The monthly revenue figure goes up and you feel no better. Or it drops and the whole week feels ruined, even though the work itself went fine. If you run a business alone, a single number carries a great deal of weight, because every swing in it reaches you personally.

This article describes a different approach: a one-page scorecard with a few measures across four layers. It is a way to see your business more completely, not a verdict on how you are doing. It takes about an hour to set up and ten minutes a week to use.

Why revenue alone misleads

Revenue tells you how much came in. It says nothing about what it cost you to earn it, how many hours it took, whether the clients were a good fit or whether you could repeat the month without wearing yourself down.

Two months with the same revenue can be very different. In one, you worked normal hours with a clear pipeline. In the other, you worked six evenings a week and took on a client you will not want again. A figure that cannot tell these apart is incomplete.

For solopreneurs the problem is amplified, because there is no separation between the business and the person. A weak month feels like a personal failing and a strong one feels like proof, though either might be down to timing, one large invoice or luck.

What makes a measure useful

Not every number deserves a place on your scorecard. In a Harvard Business Review essay on the measures of success, Michael Mauboussin argues that useful performance statistics reveal cause and effect. He describes them as persistent, meaning that similar actions produce similar results over time, and predictive, meaning that they have a causal link to the outcome you want. He also recommends defining the objective first, identifying the activities that drive it, and reviewing the measures regularly.

The essay is behind a paywall and deals with corporate metrics, so it is used here as an analogy and not as evidence about solo businesses. The idea still translates well. A good measure is one you can influence and one that tells you something about what will happen next.

Two practical filters follow from it. Prefer measures that depend on your actions, such as proposals sent, over those that depend on others, such as proposals accepted. And be careful with results that might be luck. One large project can lift a quarter without telling you anything about how the business will do next.

Start with your own definition

Before choosing any measure, write a short paragraph on what the business is for. Not the mission statement you would put on a website, but the real answer: the income you need, the way you want to spend your days, what you want to be doing in five years.

This matters because the measures should serve the definition, not replace it.

Research on goals gives one reason to take this seriously. A meta-analysis of 92 reports, available as a pre-print, found that intrinsic aspirations, such as personal growth and meaningful relationships, were positively associated with well-being. It also found that prioritising extrinsic goals, such as money and status, relative to other goals was associated with lower well-being. The authors note that extrinsic goals are not harmful in themselves. These are correlations and do not show that one causes the other, but they support the idea that income should be one part of the picture and not all of it.

Keep your paragraph short and plain. You will revisit it each quarter, and it is allowed to change.

The four layers

The scorecard has four layers: results, inputs, sustainability and meaning. Choose two or three measures for each layer at most. A scorecard with twenty items will not get read, and a scorecard that is not read does not measure anything.

Results show what the business produced. Inputs show what you did to produce it. Sustainability shows what it cost you. Meaning shows whether any of it matches what you wanted in the first place. Taken together, they give a balanced view of a month: a good number in one layer with a poor one in another is a signal to look closer.

1. Results

Results are the outcomes most people already track. Choose two.

Profit after costs is a better starting point than revenue, because it shows what you keep. If you are not sure how to calculate it, take the money received in the month and subtract business expenses and any tax set aside. The share of revenue from repeat clients is another useful measure. It shows how much of your income comes from relationships that already exist, which is usually easier and cheaper to maintain than winning new work.

Resist the urge to track ten things here. More numbers do not add insight, and most of them move together. No benchmarks are given in this article, because reliable figures for solo businesses are hard to find, and comparing yourself with an average mostly adds anxiety.

2. Inputs you control

Inputs are the activities you can do regardless of how the month turns out. They are leading indicators: they change before results do, which makes them useful for steering.

Examples include proposals sent, hours of deep work, calls booked, articles published or follow-ups completed. Choose the ones that you believe lead to your results. If you are a consultant, proposals sent and discovery calls held are probably your drivers. If you sell products, it might be the number of listings improved or emails sent.

The test comes from Mauboussin’s idea: is there a plausible link between this activity and the outcome you want? If you cannot say why an input should matter, drop it. And if it clearly matters but you rarely do it, that is an important observation in itself.

3. Sustainability

This layer is the one that solopreneurs most often skip, and the one that tells you the most about the next year.

Useful measures here are hours worked per week, days fully off, the number of evenings with unplanned work, and a simple energy rating at the end of each week on a scale from 1 to 5. The article on managing your energy, not your time describes a way to track the energy rating in more detail.

A sustainability measure can outweigh a good result. A record revenue month with seven days of work every week and an energy rating of 1 is a warning, not a success. If several sustainability measures drift the wrong way for a few weeks, read the article on the early signs of burnout when you work for yourself.

4. Your definition

The last layer connects the scorecard to the paragraph you wrote. It usually has one measure, which is a question you answer once a month.

Examples are: “Did I have enough time with my family this month?”, “Did I learn something that made me better at my work?” or “Did I have the freedom to say no to a project I did not want?” Pick the question that corresponds to what you wrote, and answer it with a score from 1 to 5 and one line of explanation.

This layer is the hardest to quantify and the easiest to skip, and it is what keeps the other three honest. If the first three layers look excellent and this one has been low for months, the business is succeeding by measures that do not matter to you.

Three example scorecards

The following examples are illustrations. They are not real businesses and do not suggest targets.

LayerConsultantCreatorProduct seller
ResultsProfit after costs; share of revenue from repeat clientsIncome from all sources; number of paying subscribersProfit after costs; return rate
InputsProposals sent; deep-work hoursPieces published; replies to readersListings improved; supplier checks
SustainabilityWeekly hours; unplanned evening workWeekly hours; days fully offWeekly hours; energy rating
Your definition“Did I have time for things outside work?”“Did I make something I’m proud of?”“Did I have a calm month?”

Each has one or two measures per layer, so the entire scorecard fits on a single page. Copy the one that is closest to your situation and change what does not fit.

A review rhythm

A scorecard that is not reviewed is only a document. Keep the rhythm light.

Once a week, spend ten minutes filling in the inputs and sustainability layers, since these change quickly. Once a month, add results and answer the question in the last layer. Once a quarter, take an hour to read the last three months together, reread your definition and ask whether the measures still make sense.

At each quarterly review, drop any measure that has never changed a decision. Mauboussin’s recommendation to re-evaluate measures regularly applies here. A measure you look at but never act on takes up space that a more useful one could have.

What to do this week

You can set this up in a single sitting.

  1. Write one paragraph on what the business is for.
  2. Choose one measure for each layer, four in total. You can add more later.
  3. Put the first review in your calendar for the end of the week, and keep it to ten minutes.

When you have run it for a month, look at what it showed you that revenue alone did not.

Related reading

Sources